By Comrade Issa Aremu mni
“A just wage for the worker is the ultimate test of whether any economic system is functioning justly.” — Pope John Paul 11
As the National tripartite negotiation is under way for a new Nationa Minimum Wage, “Minimum Wage” (MW) has regrettably assumed notoriety as a frequently misused concept. The point cannot be overstated; Minimum wage is a technical labour market concept. The International Labor Organization (ILO) is the oldest specialized agency of United Nations (UN). Established in 1919, ILO’s primary mandate “promotes social justice and internationally recognized human and labour rights” in the world of work. It was not accidental that ILO was created exactly two years after the great 1917 Bolshevik socialist revolution in Russia led by Vladimir Lenin. ILO was established to curb the spectra of social upheavals as inevitable fall-outs of the ancient regimes of indecent work and slave labour.
The goal is globalization of minimum labour standards, that include minimum wage, minimum working age (there was once gruesome labour regime of child labor that oiled the mills of the first industrial revolution). ILO sets to moderate the hitherto primitive labour market which through primitive exploitation of workers and accumulation of capital invariably pushed labour into “dangerous” and “subversive” political ideas of revolutions. Hence ILO’s founding mission of promotion of labour peace through just and fair conditions of work as indispensable success factor for global prosperity. Since it’s formation, it has initiated a number of conventions and recommendations for its 187 member states on wages and wage administration. They include Protection of Wages Convention, 1949 (No. 95), Minimum Wage Fixing Convention, 1970 (Protection of Workers’ Claims (Employer’s Insolvency) Convention, 1992: Equal Remuneration Convention, 1951 among others.
What then is Minimum Wage? The Committee of experts of the Governing Body of ILO at its 168th Session had concluded that the minimum wage (MN) “represents the lowest level of remuneration permitted, in law” paid hourly, daily or monthly. The subsisting National Minimum Wage Act of 2019, defines the minimum amount of money an employer of labour is required to pay the lowest paid worker monthly as N30,000. No other forms of wages are so legally protected, which differentiates minimum wage from any other wage awards or wage agreements. The recent commendable and responsive presidential N35,000 wage award by President Bola Tinubu for 6 months in the wake of the labour protests that trailed fuel subsidy removal remains a wage award for the federal employees. Presidential wage award is NOT a national minimum wage precisely because it is not legally supported and not earned by all workers of the Federation. National Minimum wage (MW) is the legally permissible pay below which no private or public employer should pay or bellow which no private sector or public sector worker should earn. Of course employers can and ( even encouraged) to pay above legally permissible minimum. Edo and Lagos states already pay as much as N42,000. Federal employees earn above the legal minimum while most private employers through collective bargaining for living (as distinct from minimum) pay already exceed the legal minimum. It is self evident that, the purpose of minimum wage is to protect the most vulnerable workers, often in precarious work.
National Minimum wage (MW) often impacts positivity on mass of unorganized work force. It protects workers in unorganized sectors against unacceptable miserable low pay. Every business, small or big is established to maximize profits, by minimizing costs, the significant component of which is wages. We are living in an (un)interesting times of economic crisis occasioned by collapse of the real economy and wholesale financialization in which, banks, some oil and gas companies, nonetheless still post huge profits amidst mass income poverty. Without legally permissible minimum wage, some of these employers would still pay slave wages any way. Many employers still do have them: workers whose pay can hardly make them live basic subsistence lives! Hence the need for legally permissible minimum pay. National Minimum wage (MW) is also a constitutional issue. Both 1979 and 1999 constitutions of Nigeria put labour, just like capital and financial matters, on the exclusive Federal list. 1999 constitution emphasizes that the State shall direct its policy towards ensuring “the promotion of a planned and balanced economic development; and that a reasonable national minimum living wage, old age care and pensions, and unemployment, sick benefits and welfare of the disabled are provided for all citizens”. Federal and state governments must therefore realize that they are not just employers of public employees, but they have the constitutional responsibility to protect the vulnerable workforce through enforcement of MW Act. It is unacceptable and clearly illegal that some state governments and private employers that employ not less than 50 workers to default on the subsistence pay. Indeed prompt compliance and improvement on legally permissible must be a critical success factor for good governance. The hope is that the new tripartite negotiation will ensure effective monitoring and enforcement of the minimum wage Act with respect to sanctions for non-compliance.
Definition only explains it, it however doesn’t tame Minimum wage (MN) as a concept. MN has different features in different occupations and different countries. The labour movement at regional levels had long struggled for region wide minimum wages as it was in the Western region in the 50s. Indeed some progressive politicians of social democratic persuasion during the first and second Republics had audaciously campaigned for decent work that involved minimum pay below which no worker would earn. Such as late Chief Obafemi Awolowo, the premier of the defunct Western region. Such as late Alhaji Abubakar Rimi and and Alhaji Balarabe Musa, Second Republic first democratically elected governors of Kano and Kaduna respectively. However the first national minimum wage as we know it today was in 1981 under the late President Shehu Shagari.
Precisely because yours comradely has been involved (apology to Odumegu Ojukwu), in the past decades, I bear witness that the on-going tripartite National Minimum Wage negotiation is the 6th of such since independence of the Federal Republic. Apart from 1990 minimum wage adjustment under the military regime of General Badamasi Babangida, all NMW reviews took place under democratic governments using the time tested instrumentality of tripartism. Five Tripartite Committees on National Minimum Wage (TCNMCs) took place in democratic dispensations (1981: President Shehu Shagari, 2000:President Olusegun Obasanjo, 2011: President GoodLuck Jonathan, 2018: President Muhammadu Buhari and 2024: President Bola Ahmed Tinubu). Minimum wage tripartite negotiations often involve bargaining, social dialogue and compromises on affordability and ability to pay by employers and employees alike.
Negotiation is a democratic value that thrives where there’s constitutionalism, freedoms of association and assembly. Only democratic dispensation guarantees unfettered negotiations. Military dictatorships of various hues once repressed Nigeria’s labour market with respect to minimum wage through obnoxious wage freeze, wage deflation policies as subsidy removal and Naira devaluation. Thus all tripartite stakeholders must reaffirm commitment to democracy for sustainable wage improvement through social dialogue, not arbitrary non- negotiated “wage awards”, or “wage reviews”. Minimum wage also assumes stable national macro economics of secured employment, single digit inflation and stable exchange rate. Volatility in macro economic variables, had long devalued minimum pay that is “high” in nominal terms but miserable slave pay in real terms in the wake of Naira value collapse and stag inflation. There was once a Nigeria in which MW once guaranteed minimum working and (even living) life given the macro economic stability. N125 minimum wage of 1981 was some $250 dollars (N375,000) . The current N30000, in real terms sums up to party sum $25. With January 2024, headline inflation rate at 29.90% (the highest level of inflation recorded in 28 years!) food inflation at all time high of 39.54 percent, virtually all wage earners have lost purchasing power. 2024 tripartite minimum wage committee faces the naughty task of passing the acid test of first restoring the collapsed minimum wage and at the same time ensure new rate that will make earners survive and live. The five year cycle negotiation is outdated in an era of volatility and uncertainty in macroeconomic variables. United Kingdom (UK) introduced minimum wage a decade after Nigeria started in 1981. But UK now parades a statutory Low Pay Commission (LPC) that adjusts minimum age every April 1st of the year. From April 1st 2024, for instance, Britain’s minimum wage for workers aged 21 and over rises to 11.44 pounds ($14.45) an hour “one of the highest among advanced economies”. President Bola Ahmed Tinubu should upgrade the existing National Salaries, Incomes, and Wages Commission (NSIWC) to an independent public body that should among others advise the Government on the rates of the National Minimum Wage (NMW), including the National Living Wage (NLW). NSIWC should retain its independence and identity and not merged with any agency as being proposed in the Orasanye report. At times like this, many working women and men can hardly afford three meals a day for selves, their spouses and children. Many trek to work, in the wake of transport fares hike, some even sleep at workplaces to augment transport, following fuel subsidy removal. Not few could pay for dignified abode, given prohibitive rent for the family of four. Treatments for basic ailments are unaffordable with little or nothing-out-of empty-pockets. Children are out of paying schools, no thanks to low pay. Millions of workers constitute the new working poor: workers who are getting poorer precisely because the pay for work done cannot meet their survival needs.
Happily there are enough quotable quotes on minimum and living pay attributable to President Bola Ahmed Tinubu more than any President. At the town hall meeting with organized Labour in Abuja on 19th December 2023 ahead of the 2023 Presidential election in Nigeria, he was loud and clear to say his “..government has a cardinal responsibility to work not only with business but also with labour to ensure that all constituent parts of our society are afforded their fair share of rewards without taking on undue hardship”. In his 2023 May Day speech, Tinubu also disclosed that “In the Nigeria I shall have the honour and privilege to lead from May 29, workers will have more than a minimum wage. You will have a living wage to have a decent life and provide for your families.” Organized labour through social dialogue and collective bargaining has a worthy ally on President Tinubu for a new National Minimum Living wage. ( NMLW).
Comrade Issa Aremu mni is the Director General (DG), Michael Imoudu National Institute for Labour Studies (MINILS) Ilorin
